Week 49 | November 2026

The US Navy's medium unmanned surface vessel marketplace opens its Phase II assessments today. Vendors can now bring boats forward for testing on a rolling basis until September 2031. Five years of entries, and five years of eliminations.

Every one of those eliminations now carries a question the Navy can no longer wave away. Could this end up in court?

In July I wrote about four things the Golden Fleet couldn't buy with an Other Transaction agreement: doctrine, operators, command and control, and sustainment. On 29 October a fifth turned up, in a Court of Federal Claims opinion most program offices will never read. Immunity from review isn't for sale either.

❝

Christmas break: OTI will take a break for Christmas after the 7 December Brief, which will be the 52nd edition since launch. I’ll use the time over the holidays to step back and think about what comes next. I’ll be in touch in January either way.

Two judges, opposite answers

In June 2025, Judge Richard Hertling of the Court of Federal Claims looked at an Army OT prototype competition and called the prototyping phase "an effective jurisdictional blackout." The court could review how an OT was set up, he held, and the agency's decision to buy at the end. What happened in between was off limits. The Federal Circuit, he noted, had not squarely resolved the question.

Late last month, Judge Philip Hadji, of the same court, declined to follow him. The Saildrone and Blue Water Autonomy protests against the Navy's MUSV competition fell inside the court's ordinary protest jurisdiction, he held, "because the OT competition at issue is in connection with the Navy's procurement of MUSVs."

The facts did the heavy lifting. There was a funded need, with $2.1 billion from last year's reconciliation act. There was a schedule for production awards before the end of FY2027. The solicitation called itself a direct, competitive down-select for production, issued by a Navy that said it was no longer interested in paying industry to build prototypes. And Phase 1 of that solicitation was the only door to its production contract. Lose there, and you were out of that competition. (The separate Phase II call opening today is a second door.)

The government's "non-procurement OT" framing got short shrift. It is, Hadji wrote, "just a label coined and brandished by the Government." Deferring review until the Navy declared a prototype successful "would leave that offeror without a forum until the competition it challenges has run its course and would leave the timing of this Court's jurisdiction to the agency's own determination." The blackout, he added, "fits this record poorly," since Telesto concerned a multi-year R&D effort.

The opinion is careful about its limits. An OT whose principal purpose is funding research or growing a commercial market stays outside. OTs remain exempt from the FAR and the Competition in Contracting Act. Review reaches the Navy's compliance with section 4022's own conditions and the solicitation's terms, and stops there.

So where does an eliminated vendor go? GAO still generally declines OT protests, although it has taken jurisdiction over at least one multi-phase competition that could end in a contract, and a Court of Federal Claims ruling doesn't bind it anyway. Telesto pointed to federal district court instead, which Hadji said would split one acquisition between courts. The Federal Circuit "has not addressed" the question. Several of Hadji's colleagues had already accepted OT protests; Hertling's blackout is the narrower view. Cases are randomly assigned unless they relate to an earlier one, so a first-time protester can't know which reading it will get.

The record is the product now

The merits ruling was filed under seal on 30 October and reissued publicly on 3 November. Program offices should start reading there.

Saildrone won. The Navy had cut its Spectre proposal because loaded displacement figures exceeded the stated maximum. Sea Machines advanced with a placemat that showed the same discrepancy for one of its vessels and left the fields blank for the other. The Navy, the court found, "disparately favored Sea Machines and arbitrarily held Saildrone to a higher standard."

Blue Water lost. The solicitation asked for a representative test vessel. Blue Water's was a twin-hull catamaran with a direct-drive plant; its production design was an axe-bow monohull running diesel-electric. The Navy's evaluation dealt with it in two short sentences: "Fail – unrepresentative test vessel. Entirely different hullform and machinery layout." Its debrief then explained why each difference mattered for the test, down to how the machinery control system would talk to the autonomy. The Navy, the court said, "did more than invoke its expertise," and it "reasonably rated Blue Water unacceptable."

Read those two outcomes side by side. Blue Water's rating rested on a reason written down at the time and explained consistently afterwards, and it held. Saildrone's case shows the reverse. When the government argued its proposal lacked supporting evidence, the court pointed out that neither the evaluation nor the debrief said so: "That characterization comes from counsel, not the Navy." What sank the Navy on Saildrone was inconsistency: one standard for one vendor, a stricter one for another.

Then there's the remand order. The Navy has 60 days to reevaluate Saildrone, applying the same approach it used for the proposals it advanced, and it "shall document its evaluation in a manner sufficient for judicial review."

That clause is the institutional gap in a sentence. The marketplace was built for rolling entry and quick decisions, run by program offices set up for fast OT work. Five years of Phase II eliminations will each now generate a file a judge might read. Someone has to write those files for an adversarial reader. I'd be surprised if that's in anyone's manning plan.

Bill Greenwalt, a former deputy under secretary of defense for industrial policy now at AEI, told USNI News that expanding protest jurisdiction "has a significant potential to destroy OTA authority as a fast alternative to developing new capabilities." He also told USNI that contracting officers using the authority "as a ruse to eventually award to traditional contractors" deserve "to be called out on the carpet." Both can be true. My view is simpler. Applying one standard to every vendor costs very little. Applying two was always the risk, and now there's a forum that will say so.

$255 million

Here's the number most of the coverage missed.

The injunction was widely reported as a $1.5 billion cap on a $2.1 billion program. According to the court, the Navy has already made about $1.245 billion in follow-on production awards. On those figures, until seven days after it finishes the reevaluation and tells Saildrone the result in writing, it can obligate roughly $255 million more. The government filed its report on actual obligations under seal on 12 November, so the court’s number is the best public figure.

The cap also reaches past this solicitation. It covers obligations from that appropriation "under any other solicitation, authority, agreement, or other transaction." If Phase II orders draw on the same money, they sit inside it too.

In Nine Builders, Three Boats I argued the year that bought 30 boats was the peak. The next round of buying may now run partly under a court order.

This one isn't finished. The remand runs out around 29 December, and the government's window to appeal the injunction likely closes around the same time. The Pentagon has told USNI only that it will "develop next steps once the litigation is resolved." Meanwhile the House version of the FY27 NDAA would rewrite section 4022's conditions for using prototype OTs, and let officials treat demonstrated performance and speed of delivery as the primary factors in structuring an award. Those conditions are what Hadji said the court can now review. If the change survives conference, Congress will be redrawing the test just as a court has started applying it.

Since you have been, thanks for reading. 

Cheers, 

Mick

Ocean Tech Intelligence provides informational analysis only. Nothing in this publication constitutes financial, investment, legal, or strategic advice. Readers act on this content at their own risk. For full details see our Disclaimer.